Supreme Court to hear religious liberty case over home prayer gathering By HENRY DURAND, The Christian Index Thursday, November 19, 2026 WASHINGTON — In January 2021, Daniel Grand invited about a dozen friends to his home for a Sabbath prayer gathering. He had no idea the invitation would lead to a legal battle that, nearly six years later, has reached the U.S. Supreme Court. Before the group had met even once, the city of University Heights sent him a cease-and-desist letter directing him to stop using his home as a “place of religious assembly.” Justices are scheduled to hear arguments Dec. 9 in the case. Religious groups supporting Grand include the Southern Baptist Convention’s Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission. Grand is an Orthodox Jew whose faith calls him to pray with a minyan, a quorum of at least 10 men, three times each weekday and four times on the Sabbath and Jewish holidays. Orthodox Jews do not drive during the Sabbath. Attending all four Sabbath services at the nearest synagogue required four round trips totaling roughly six miles. Grand said the walk could be difficult for people with young children or physical limitations, particularly in extreme weather. Grand decided to host a minyan in his home and emailed friends who lived nearby. The next afternoon, he said, then-Mayor Michael Dylan Brennan left Grand a message asking him to call about what Brennan described as an “urgent matter.” Before Grand returned the call, the city’s law director sent the cease-and-desist letter. Grand says Brennan later told him, “You are under no circumstances allowed to have any type of religious gathering in your home without first obtaining a special-use permit.” Grand canceled the gathering. In a first-person account published by Alliance Defending Freedom, which now represents him before the Supreme Court along with Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, Grand wrote, “I understood this to be a threat of criminal prosecution.” The city told Grand he needed a special-use permit, so he applied and appeared before the University Heights Planning Commission. He later withdrew the application, saying he never intended to operate a formal house of worship in his home. “The problem wasn’t just that I had trouble getting the permit but that the city demanded I get one in the first place,” he wrote. Grand says that city officials encouraged neighbors to monitor his home, directed police to make drive-bys, pursued housing-code violations, withheld his certificate of occupancy and tax abatements, and repeatedly failed to collect his trash. University Heights disputes Grand’s characterization of the case. The city says its zoning laws do not prohibit small prayer groups in homes and that the Planning Commission never made a final determination that Grand needed a special-use permit for the gathering he ultimately described. City attorneys say Grand’s original invitation referred to the gathering as a “shul” and the inauguration of a “Beis Hakeneset,” or house of assembly. Those descriptions, the city says, raised the question of whether Grand intended to establish a formal house of worship subject to zoning requirements. “If my next-door neighbor invited friends over for a weekly poker night or Book of the Month Club meeting, the city wouldn’t require a special permit,” Grand wrote. “They shouldn’t require one for a prayer meeting, either.” Grand filed a federal civil-rights lawsuit in 2022. A federal district court dismissed the case, and the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision in November 2025. The appeals court ruled that Grand’s principal claims were not ripe for federal review because he withdrew his application before city zoning officials reached a final decision. The Supreme Court is not being asked whether the city violated Grand’s religious liberty rights. Instead, the justices will decide whether Grand had to finish the city’s zoning process before suing, or whether the city’s warning and his decision to cancel the prayer gathering were enough to bring the case to court. Grand argues that his rights were violated when the city told him he could not hold the gathering without a permit. “No American needs a permit to pray,” said Alliance Defending Freedom Senior Counsel John Bursch, who is representing Grand. The federal government has filed a brief supporting Grand, along with 14 states, 51 members of Congress, and a number of religious organizations. The U.S. Solicitor General has also been granted time to participate in oral arguments. Grand sold his University Heights home and moved outside the city in July. University Heights argues that the move makes his challenge moot because he is no longer subject to the city’s zoning ordinance. Grand’s attorneys say the case remains alive because he is seeking relief for injuries he says have already occurred, including damages. Southern Baptist concerns The ERLC joined the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in a friend-of-the-court brief supporting Grand. The ERLC said the case matters to Southern Baptists because religious exercise “has never been confined to the church sanctuary.” “For Southern Baptists, then, the freedoms of religion and assembly meet in a particularly tangible way in the home,” the commission said. “Gathering there to pray, study Scripture, worship, fellowship, and share the gospel is part of the ordinary practice of their faith.” The ERLC also cited the Southern Baptist Convention’s 2026 resolution “On the 250th Anniversary of the United States and the Baptist Contribution to Religious Liberty,” in which messengers affirmed their “historic Baptist commitment to religious liberty for all people” as “a God-given right grounded in the dignity of every human being made in the image of God.” “I’m asking the Court to let my case proceed in a lower court because my constitutional rights were violated the moment the city told me I couldn’t pray in my home with my friends,” Grand wrote. Mike Griffin, public affairs representative for the Georgia Baptist Mission Board, said, “It’s imperative that we always stand up for religious freedom. Our First Amendment rights are strategic in protecting the Constitution of our great nation.” Prayer ahead of Dec. 9 Alliance Defending Freedom is organizing a nationwide prayer effort ahead of the Dec. 9 hearing. Through its #PrayFreely campaign, ADF is asking churches, Bible studies, prayer groups, and other small groups to pray for the case in the weeks before Dec. 9 and to pray together on the morning of oral arguments. Groups that sign up for the campaign receive a prayer guide for use during their regular meetings. ADF is also encouraging participating groups to share photos of their groups praying together. “God calls us to stand up for His name,” Grand wrote. “Until He takes me off the earth, I’m not going to stop being faithful to that call.” --- PHOTOS --- File: 20260625-132526-259-AP26138777228543.jpg Caption: The Supreme Court is seen in Washington, May 18, 2026. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)